• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
    • Our Attorneys
    • Our Staff
      • Sheila Chavez
      • Marin Gorman
    • Mission Statement
    • Community Service
    • Charities We Support
    • Secret Settlements – Our Stand
    • Patrick Malone & Associates Offers Scholarship to Law Students for Representing Real People
  • Attorneys
    • Patrick Malone
    • Daniel C. Scialpi
    • Alfred Clarke
    • Heather J. Kelly
    • Aaron M. Levine, Of Counsel
    • Peter R. Masciola, Of Counsel
  • Focus Areas
    • Medical Malpractice
      • Hospital Errors
      • Cancer Misdiagnosis
      • Diabetes
      • Kaiser HMO Malpractice
      • Military Malpractice
      • Hospital Security Misconduct
    • Brain and Spinal Cord Injuries
      • Brain Injuries From Medical Care
      • Lead Poisoning
      • Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)
      • TBI Long-Term Care & Rehabilitation
    • Baby & Child Injuries
      • Birth Injuries
      • Infant/Child Brain Injuries
      • Shaken Baby Syndrome
      • Pediatric Anesthesia Errors
      • Jaundice/Kernicterus
      • Bacterial Meningitis
    • Sex Abuse of Children and Youths
      • Sexual Abuse Claims in Washington D.C.
    • Auto, Truck, and Motorcycle Accidents
      • Car Accidents
        • Maryland Car Accidents
        • Virginia Car Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Train Accidents
    • Defective & Dangerous Products
    • Dangerous Drugs
      • Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
    • Nursing Home Neglect and Abuse
    • Consumer Rights
    • Accounting and Legal Malpractice
      • How To Sue Your Lawyer For Malpractice
      • Common Legal Malpractice Claims
      • Damages For Legal Malpractice
      • Missing The Deadline For A Lawsuit
  • Success
    • Verdicts & Settlements
    • What Our Clients Say
    • True Stories
  • Publications
  • Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Steps in the Legal Process
    • The Jury Trial System
    • Legal Deadlines for Filing Your Personal Injury Lawsuit
    • Better Health Care Newsletter from Patrick Malone
    • Sign Up for Our Free Newsletter on Getting Better Health Care
    • Free Fact Kit for Injury Victims
    • Tips for Patient Safety and Better Health Care
    • Health Care Advocates’ Power Kit
    • For Attorneys
    • More Legal Resources
    • Fellow Inner Circle Members
    • DC Hospital Ratings Map
    • Motor Vehicle Accident Blog
    • Washington D.C. Bike Map
    • Commute Risk Calculator
  • Patient Safety Blog
    • ProtectPatientsBlog.com
  • Malpractice A-Z
  • Contact Us

Patrick Malone Law

Medical Malpractice & Personal Injury Law Firm | Patrick Malone Law

CALL US TODAY:

202-742-1500
888-625-6635

Are You A Lawyer Seeking Co-Counsel ?
  • About Us
    • Our Attorneys
    • Our Staff
      • Sheila Chavez
      • Marin Gorman
    • Mission Statement
    • Community Service
    • Charities We Support
    • Secret Settlements – Our Stand
    • Patrick Malone & Associates Offers Scholarship to Law Students for Representing Real People
  • Attorneys
    • Patrick Malone
    • Daniel C. Scialpi
    • Alfred Clarke
    • Heather J. Kelly
    • Aaron M. Levine, Of Counsel
    • Peter R. Masciola, Of Counsel
  • Focus Areas
    • Medical Malpractice
      • Hospital Errors
      • Cancer Misdiagnosis
      • Diabetes
      • Kaiser HMO Malpractice
      • Military Malpractice
      • Hospital Security Misconduct
    • Brain and Spinal Cord Injuries
      • Brain Injuries From Medical Care
      • Lead Poisoning
      • Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)
      • TBI Long-Term Care & Rehabilitation
    • Baby & Child Injuries
      • Birth Injuries
      • Infant/Child Brain Injuries
      • Shaken Baby Syndrome
      • Pediatric Anesthesia Errors
      • Jaundice/Kernicterus
      • Bacterial Meningitis
    • Sex Abuse of Children and Youths
      • Sexual Abuse Claims in Washington D.C.
    • Auto, Truck, and Motorcycle Accidents
      • Car Accidents
        • Maryland Car Accidents
        • Virginia Car Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Train Accidents
    • Defective & Dangerous Products
    • Dangerous Drugs
      • Carbon Monoxide Poisoning
    • Nursing Home Neglect and Abuse
    • Consumer Rights
    • Accounting and Legal Malpractice
      • How To Sue Your Lawyer For Malpractice
      • Common Legal Malpractice Claims
      • Damages For Legal Malpractice
      • Missing The Deadline For A Lawsuit
  • Success
    • Verdicts & Settlements
    • What Our Clients Say
    • True Stories
  • Publications
  • Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Steps in the Legal Process
    • The Jury Trial System
    • Legal Deadlines for Filing Your Personal Injury Lawsuit
    • Better Health Care Newsletter from Patrick Malone
    • Sign Up for Our Free Newsletter on Getting Better Health Care
    • Free Fact Kit for Injury Victims
    • Tips for Patient Safety and Better Health Care
    • Health Care Advocates’ Power Kit
    • For Attorneys
    • More Legal Resources
    • Fellow Inner Circle Members
    • DC Hospital Ratings Map
    • Motor Vehicle Accident Blog
    • Washington D.C. Bike Map
    • Commute Risk Calculator
  • Patient Safety Blog
    • ProtectPatientsBlog.com
  • Malpractice A-Z
  • Contact Us
Call
Contact
Blog
You are here: Home / Better Health Care Newsletter by Patrick Malone / July 2013

July 2013

Navigating Through Medical Treatment Conflicts of Interest

Dear Readers,

Our collective minds continue to reel at the unsavory relationship of some doctors with pharmaceutical and medical device companies. But why should patients really care? And what can we do about it?

We all know that money talks, and Big Money — i.e., Big Pharma and Big Device Manufacturers — talks long and loud with the doctors who make key decisions about our health care.

Last month came news of yet more back-scratching between doctors and Big Pharma: At least 17 of Medicare’s top 20 prescribers of the blood pressure drug Bystolic were paid by the manufacturer to promote it. They got $283,450 for the speeches and more than $20,000 in meals.

When a corporation pays practitioners to speak at a conference, participate in research, to travel, dine and play golf, conflicts of interest arise–if the doctor has a choice of implant devices, and if the manufacturer of one of them has fed the doctor’s belly, which device is the doctor more likely to choose?

So what’s best for the patient isn’t always–or maybe usually–the top priority.

This month’s topic: Where can patients find independent, conflict-free sources of advice about medical treatments?

Is There a Problem? Let Us Count the Ways

In some cases, the appearance of a conflict of interest turns into legal inquiry. As noted in the Bystolic story from ProPublica, the nonprofit investigative journalism group, Forest Laboratory, the manufacturer of Bystolic, paid $313 million to settle civil and criminal allegations for, among other things, how it marketed drugs. The government charged that Forest made “cash payments disguised as grants or consulting fees, expensive meals and lavish entertainment, and other valuable goods and services” to doctors.

Earlier this year, a lawsuit against Norvartis alleged that the company’s internal analyses showed that the money it spent to hire speakers spurred the doctors who participated to write more prescriptions for its drugs. Novartis disputed the allegations, but a couple of years ago pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor and paid $422.5 million to settle allegations that it illegally promoted an antiseizure drug, and paid kickbacks for prescribing it and other drugs.

Last year, our Patient Safety blog  detailed slimy behavior by GlaxoSmithKline:

  • It paid media hound Dr. Drew Pinsky $275,000 to promote the depression drug Wellbutrin; on one of his radio shows, he claimed the drug “could explain a woman suddenly having 60 orgasms in one night,” never mind that Wellbutrin was approved to treat only major depression.
  • It flew psychiatrists to fancy resorts to promote Paxil, another of its depression drugs, for children, even though it was unapproved for that use. “Results suggest that the Paxil Forum had a significant impact on Paxil market share in the months after attendance,” according to a Glaxo memo.
  • It paid what prosecutors called kickbacks to doctors in the form of consulting fees, entertainment, travel and “sham advisory boards,” then tracked their prescribing habits and gave those who frequently prescribed their drugs free tickets to sports events.
  • In some cases, as our blog has noted, some drugs (Vioxx, for arthritis, and Baycol, for cholesterol) were deemed safe, but later withdrawn from the market. Turned out that reports championing them and published in scientific journals were written by drug companies.

Invariably, drug and device manufacturers claim that they choose doctors to speak because they have certain expertise and credentials, not because they agree to play for pay. But they end up shelling out a lot of money over their promotional behavior.

A Growing Awareness

Several factors have brought this smarmy situation into the sunlight.

In addition to drug shenanigans, inappropriate tests that increase costs and that can have adverse medical outcomes–see our blog, “Overtested, Overtreated, Overcharged“–are being questioned by more and more practitioners and patients.

And the regulatory environment is changing: The Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”) includes carrots and sticks to improve patient outcomes and to punish providers who don’t measure up. The ACA analyzes quality–an example is keying hospitals’ reimbursement to their rates of readmission–and strives to make sure providers, patients and insurers understand common standards.

That’s not about conflict of interest, but it is about quantifying all aspects of medical care and its outcomes, and with that sort of scrutiny you find out all kinds of things you didn’t know were occurring.

In the prescribing realm, some drug companies post doctor payment information on their web sites, sometimes as part of a legal settlement with the federal government. And the ACA’s Physician Payments Sunshine Act requires manufacturers of drugs, medical devices and biologicals that participate in Medicare or Medicaid to report payments and items of value given to physicians who aren’t their employees, and to teaching hospitals. The federal government will post the information on a public web site sometime next year.

Getting Objective Information

Just because a provider accepts pay from a medical drug or device manufacturer, that doesn’t mean he or she prescribes medicine or chooses a test or device solely because of it. But it does mean you need to step up your own research. You must ask why that treatment was chosen, what results is it supposed to bring, how fast, with what potential side effects, and if there are alternative treatments.

The purpose of this newsletter and the following resources is to help you understand and manage the risk that comes with any medical intervention.

There are several ways consumers can do their own research.

ProPublica was the first organization to research and post associations between drug companies and the doctors they do business with. Dollars for Docs can search information for 15 (so far) drug and device companies and what they pay to doctors. You can search by company, by state and by provider.

Prescriber Checkup enables you to search Medicare’s prescription drug program that serves more than 35 million people. Until now, the names of prescribers and the drugs they choose have not been made public. This tool finds and compares doctors and other top prescribers.

The Independent Drug Information Service (IDIS) was established to provide physicians with objective, scientific information to guide them in prescribing drugs. It’s a nonprofit with no ties to drug companies. It was created by an independent group of physicians and researchers from Harvard Medical School.

IDIS has a page for patients to learn about common health conditions and the drugs to treat them. The information is solid, but the site does not, at this writing, have a search function.

Medline Plus is published by the National Institutes of Health. It’s a vast resource for all things medical, including drug and medical device information, including safety and recall information. 

MedWatch is the FDA’s repository for safety information and adverse event reports. You can read about recalls, subscribe to safety alerts and file reports of your own.

Here’s to a healthy 2013!

Sincerely,
  signature block

Patrick Malone
Patrick Malone & Associates

Primary Sidebar

Contact Us

Focus Areas

  • Medical Malpractice
  • Birth Injury
  • Auto, Truck & Motorcycle Accidents
  • Brain & Spinal Cord Injuries
  • Defective Products
  • Dangerous Drugs
  • Nursing Home Neglect & Abuse
  • Consumer Rights
  • Accounting & Legal Malpractice

Resources

The Lawsuit Process
  • Free Fact Kit for injury victims
  • FAQs about injuries & the legal process
  • Steps in the legal process
  • Legal deadlines for your lawsuit
  • What to expect from your “independent” medical examination
  • The jury trial system
Medical Resources
  • Patient Safety Tips
  • Health Care Advocates’ Power Kit
  • DC Hospital Rating Map
  • Patient Safety Newsletter
    from Patrick Malone
For Attorneys
  • Books for Attorneys
  • Expert Witness Resources
  • Articles
  • Briefs
  • Closing Arguments in Trial
  • Medical Society Statements on Expert Witness Testimony
  • Cross Examination Transcripts

What Our Clients Say

  • Client reviews on
  • Client reviews on
View more

Patient Safety Blog by Patrick Malone & Associates

  • Communication
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Medications
  • Hospitals
  • Preventive Care
  • Research Studies
  • Accessibility of Health Care
  • Disclosure
  • Primary Care
  • Product Safety
View More Topics

Footer

Our Location

  • PATRICK MALONE & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

    1310 L Street NW
    Suite 800
    Washington, DC 20005

  • Phone: (202) 742-1500
  • Toll Free: (888) 625-6635
  • EMAIL
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Linkedin

What We Do

  • Brain And Spinal Cord Injuries
  • Medical Malpractice
  • Birth Injury
  • Auto, Truck And Motorcycle Injuries
  • Defective And Dangerous Products
  • Dangerous Drugs
  • Nursing Home Neglect And Abuse
  • Consumer Rights
  • Accounting and Legal Malpractice

Directions

Get Directions

© 2023 Patrick Malone & Associates, P.C. | All Rights Reserved | Legal Notice